Dear Evan Hansen Movie: Why It Flopped and Controversies

Few movie adaptations generate as much head-scratching as the 2021 film version of Dear Evan Hansen. A Broadway phenomenon with a Tony-winning score and a deeply emotional story, the transition to the big screen was supposed to be a safe bet. Instead, it landed with a 28% critics score on Rotten Tomatoes and sparked a wave of controversy that turned a potential hit into a cultural flashpoint.

Release date: September 24, 2021 (Universal Pictures) Directed by: Stephen Chbosky (Universal Pictures) Rotten Tomatoes critics score: 28% (Counterpoint)

Nine key facts about the movie, one pattern: most of the data points that usually define a film’s profile are backed by official sources, but the critical backlash relies on independent commentary.

Why Don’t People Like the Dear Evan Hansen Movie?

Casting Controversy: Ben Platt’s Age

• Ben Platt was criticized for playing a teenager while visibly older (YouTube – Ben Platt Responds)
• Critics argued the age gap undermined the immersion (Counterpoint)

Platt addressed the backlash directly, acknowledging the optics while defending his connection to the character.

Changes from the Musical

• The adaptation cut or altered key songs and scenes (Counterpoint)
• The film softened Evan’s moral complexity compared to the stage version (Counterpoint)

“The film struggles to capture the intimacy of the stage production, and Platt’s performance feels out of step.”

Counterpoint

The implication: the stage show’s power came from live intimacy, a quality the film version could not replicate.

Plot Issues: The Uncomfortable Lie

• The story asks viewers to sympathize with a protagonist who builds a false narrative around a classmate’s suicide (FilmSpeak)
• Critics found the tone mismatched and the exploitation uncomfortable (FilmSpeak)

Box Office Performance and Financial Flop

• The film underperformed relative to its production cost, widely described as a box office bomb (Counterpoint)
• Audience scores on PostTrak were low, indicating poor word of mouth (Counterpoint)

The pattern: a beloved musical does not automatically translate to a beloved movie. The critical and commercial failure of Dear Evan Hansen shows how deeply adaptation choices matter.

What Was Evan Hansen Diagnosed With?

Evan Hansen’s Diagnosis in the Musical and Movie

• The character is portrayed as having social anxiety disorder, though it is not explicitly named in the film (Universal Pictures)
• The musical’s book by Steven Levenson centers anxiety as a core theme (Universal Pictures)

“I understand the optics. But I believed in the story and the character.”

Ben Platt, in an interview with The New York Times (via YouTube)

Portrayal of Social Anxiety and Depression

Platt’s performance attempts to show internal struggle, but some critics felt the film’s tone undermined the seriousness (FilmSpeak). What this means: the film’s handling of mental health was a lightning rod. Critics wanted more nuance; fans of the musical felt the stage version handled it better.

Was Dear Evan Hansen Based Off a True Story?

Real-Life Inspiration Behind the Story

• Dear Evan Hansen is not based on a true story (Universal Pictures)
• The musical was written by Steven Levenson with music by Benj Pasek and Justin Paul (Universal Pictures)

Fictional Elements and Original Creation

• All characters and events are fictional (Universal Pictures)

The catch: the story feels so specific that many assume it must be true, but the creators have consistently stated it is entirely imagined.

Is There Homosexuality in Dear Evan Hansen?

Queer Coding and Fan Interpretations

• No explicit homosexuality is depicted in the film (Universal Pictures)
• Some viewers interpret Evan’s relationship with Connor as potentially romantic, but it is not confirmed (Counterpoint)

Official Statements from Creators

• The creators have not intended a queer storyline (Counterpoint)

What Is the Biggest Flop in Movie History?

Defining a Box Office Bomb

• Dear Evan Hansen is not the biggest flop in movie history (Counterpoint)
• Larger flops include John Carter, The Adventures of Pluto Nash, and Howard the Duck (Counterpoint)

Comparison to Historical Flops

• The film’s budget of $28 million and global box office of $19.1 million (as reported in industry tracking) made it a financial disappointment, but not the worst ever (Counterpoint)

The trade-off: calling it the biggest flop is an exaggeration, but its failure relative to expectations made it a cautionary tale for Hollywood.

Timeline of Key Events

• 2015: Broadway musical premieres
• June 2016: Transfers to Music Box Theatre
• November 2018: Film adaptation announced with Ben Platt attached (Universal Pictures)
• January 2020: Filming begins in Los Angeles
• May 2021: First teaser trailer released
• September 24, 2021: Theatrical release (Universal Pictures)
• October 2021: Digital release; controversy peaks

Clarity: What We Know vs. What Remains Unclear

Confirmed Findings

• Release date, director, and source material confirmed by official studio (Universal Pictures)
• 28% Rotten Tomatoes score (as of September 2021) (Counterpoint)
• Not based on a true story (Universal Pictures)

Uncertainties and Open Questions

• Exact LGBTQ+ content status – no official confirmation
• Whether the casting age controversy directly caused the box office underperformance
• Long-term legacy vs. immediate reception

“We wanted to make the movie its own thing while honoring the musical.”

Stephen Chbosky, director, in an interview (via Counterpoint)

“The film is a tone-deaf and exploitative misfire.”

FilmSpeak

The Dear Evan Hansen movie will be remembered as a case study in adaptation missteps. For fans of the musical, the film failed to capture the intimacy and moral ambiguity that made the stage version powerful. For newcomers, the uncomfortable premise was hard to embrace. The implication for Hollywood is clear: a hit stage show does not guarantee a hit movie, and casting choices can make or break audience trust.

För den som vill veta mer om huvudrollsinnehavaren finns Ben Platts fullständiga karriäröversikt som täcker både Broadway och film.

Frequently asked questions