My Fair Lady Cast: Broadway, 1964 Film and 2024 Tour

Broadway opening: March 15, 1956 (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia)) · Film release year: 1964 (American Film Institute (official film catalog)) · Film Academy Awards: 8 wins (Britannica (encyclopedic reference)) · Singing voice in the 1964 film: Marni Nixon (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia)) · Tony Awards: 6 of 10 nominations (Yakima Herald (regional newspaper))

Eight dated facts hold the record together, and one pattern stands out: the 1956 stage run is documented in far more detail than the 1964 film.

Who played My Fair Lady on Broadway?

The original production opened at the Mark Hellinger Theatre in New York City on March 15, 1956, according to Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia). Julie Andrews and Rex Harrison led the cast, joined by Stanley Holloway as Alfred P. Doolittle, Robert Coote as Colonel Pickering, Cathleen Nesbitt as Mrs. Higgins and John Michael King as Freddy Eynsford-Hill.

Julie Andrews as Eliza Doolittle in the 1956 original

• Created the role of Eliza Doolittle on Broadway in 1956 (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))
• Left the role when Sally Ann Howes took over as Eliza on February 3, 1958 (Internet Broadway Database (Broadway production records))

Rex Harrison as Henry Higgins on Broadway

• Led the original cast as Henry Higgins opposite Andrews (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))
• Replaced by Edward Mulhare in November 1957 (Internet Broadway Database (Broadway production records))

Stanley Holloway as Alfred Doolittle

• Played Alfred P. Doolittle in the Broadway cast, as listed in the original cast record (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))

The implication: searching for the original Broadway cast means searching for a sequence of performers, not one fixed lineup.

Was Audrey Hepburn actually singing in My Fair Lady?

Audrey Hepburn did not provide her own singing voice in the 1964 film. According to Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia), Marni Nixon dubbed those songs. The casting decision itself is also on record: Yakima Herald (regional newspaper) reports that a Warner Bros. studio head chose Hepburn for the part.

Marni Nixon and the film singing voice

• Marni Nixon provided the singing voice for Hepburn in the 1964 film (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))
• The film was directed by George Cukor and adapted by Alan Jay Lerner, according to its own Wikipedia entry (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))

Hepburn’s performance and the dubbing decision

• Hepburn was chosen by a Warner Bros. studio head (Yakima Herald (regional newspaper))
• The film premiered October 21, 1964 at New York’s Criterion Theatre (American Film Institute (official film catalog))

The catch: the star’s name headlines the film, but the sung voice belongs to Nixon, so a reader checking the credits has to look past the headline.

Was Julie Andrews ever in My Fair Lady?

Yes, on stage. Andrews created Eliza on Broadway in 1956, and the replacement record shows when she left the role (Internet Broadway Database (Broadway production records)). No, not in the film. The casting shift was set in May 1962, when Hepburn was cast and Andrews was not (American Film Institute (official film catalog)).

Julie Andrews’s original Broadway run as Eliza

• Created the role on Broadway opposite Rex Harrison as Higgins (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))
• Her exit came through the February 3, 1958 replacement by Sally Ann Howes (Internet Broadway Database (Broadway production records))

Why the 1964 film was cast with Audrey Hepburn

• Warner Bros. chose Hepburn, and Andrews was not cast (Yakima Herald (regional newspaper))
• Rex Harrison stayed on as Higgins in the film, opposite Hepburn (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))

The implication: an original-cast credit on Broadway does not carry over to the screen when a studio recasts the lead.

How old is Eliza supposed to be in My Fair Lady?

One production breakdown gives a specific answer: a Soo Theatre character listing puts Eliza’s age at 20 to 30. That listing is a production choice, not a direct quotation from Shaw’s text, and we could not trace it to a link we can publish, so the range stays unverified.

Age range in a production breakdown

• A Soo Theatre character breakdown lists Eliza’s age range as 20 to 30 (listing without a published link; unverified)
• The range comes from a production listing, not from the text of the play

Why casting age varies between productions

• Casting age differs between productions and between performers
• One listing records one staging’s choice, not a settled rule for the role

The catch: the age question has no sourced answer yet, so the 20-to-30 range is the best available listing, not the play’s requirement.

Did Rex Harrison and Audrey Hepburn get along?

Both starred in the 1964 film, with Hepburn as Eliza and Harrison as Higgins, per Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia). Nothing in the sources gathered for this piece documents how the two got along or worked together.

What the sources document

• Harrison played Henry Higgins opposite Hepburn in the 1964 film (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))
• Hepburn replaced Julie Andrews as Eliza for the film (Yakima Herald (regional newspaper))

What remains unverified

• No source gathered for this piece documents a personal or working relationship between the two
• Any claim about their on-set dynamic needs a named, dated source before publication

Why this matters: rapport stories spread without dates or bylines, so the sourced answer is the pairing on screen and nothing more.

Timeline of the casting record

• March 15, 1956: the Broadway production opens at the Mark Hellinger Theatre (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))
• April 2, 1956: the original cast recording is released by Columbia Records and becomes the best-selling album in the United States that year, according to Wikipedia (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))
• November 1957: Edward Mulhare replaces Rex Harrison (Internet Broadway Database (Broadway production records))
• February 3, 1958: Sally Ann Howes replaces Julie Andrews (Internet Broadway Database (Broadway production records))
• 1958 or 1959: the West End opening, where sources disagree (Britannica (encyclopedic reference); Theatre Heritage Australia (theatre history archive))
• May 1962: Hepburn is cast as Eliza in the film, and Andrews is not (American Film Institute (official film catalog))
• September 29, 1962: the Broadway run closes after 2,717 performances (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))
• October 21, 1964: the film premieres at the Criterion Theatre in New York (American Film Institute (official film catalog))
• April 19, 2018: the Lincoln Center Theater revival opens on Broadway (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))
• December 2019: a North American tour opens with Shereen Ahmed and Laird Mackintosh, then pauses for COVID-19 in March 2020 and resumes in September 2021 (Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia))
• April 16 and 17, 2024: tour performances at the Capitol Theatre in Yakima (Yakima Herald (regional newspaper))

The pattern: the lineup changed fastest in the first two years, while the 2018 revival and the 2024 tour sit far from that early churn.

Confirmed facts and open questions

The trade-off: the confirmed column is short because the sourcing is thin, not because the production story is quiet.

What the sources say

“While it was a much later rebroadcast of the 1964 film adaptation that I first fell in love with, the original Broadway production of ‘My Fair Lady’ premiered in 1956.”

Unnamed columnist, Yakima Herald (regional newspaper)

“The casting of Audrey Hepburn as Eliza created controversy among theatregoers, both because Andrews was regarded as perfect in the part and because Hepburn’s singing voice was dubbed (by Marni Nixon).”

Wikipedia contributors, Wikipedia (community-edited encyclopedia)

The implication: two different records agree on the 1956 Broadway premiere, but only the encyclopedia entry addresses the controversy over the film’s dubbing.

Where the cast record stands

The Broadway cast is the best-documented part of this story, with dated replacements, a run length and an awards record that trace back to named sources. The 1964 film is well documented on its premiere and Academy Awards but thin on how its performances were decided, and the 2024 tour is still a set of dates without a confirmed cast. Film students who cite the American Film Institute, Internet Broadway Database and Wikipedia get dated, checkable facts; anyone repeating an on-set or tour-cast claim should hold it until a dated primary source backs it.

The implication: a sourced cast history rests on dated replacements and premiere records, not on rapport stories.

Related reading: Cast of Oliver! (1968 Film): Full Cast and Main Roles ? Carry On Cast: Who Starred in the Classic British Films

Frequently asked questions